Friday, 16 July 2010 09:16

Legal Entity Simplification: Impossible?

Written by Kelley Lear

This blog is the first in a two-part series regarding Corporate Legal Entity Simplification, inspired by Red Moon Solutions Managing Director Kelley Lear’s participation in the Chicago Tax Club (CTC) meetings in June.

Although I truly never think that legal entity structures ever could be considered “simple” or in any way “simplified”, I was able to participate in a presentation that at the very least walked us through the issues and structural changes so that even I was able to follow along. In a previous series, I blogged about a session regarding outrageous cases that have hit the tax case law books this year as they continue to irritate corporate tax departments and tax attorneys alike.  Today I have a few words regarding the session on Corporate Legal Entity Simplification.

Todd Miller (Ernst & Young’s Transaction Advisory Services National Leader – Section 382 and Basis Studies, Tax Sell-Side Practice) and Michelle Brady (Ernst & Young’s Transaction Advisory Services Senior Manager) presented a dive into corporate reorganizations/structures.   The agenda covered such topics as:

1.    Corporate reorganizations and business purpose
2.    Codification of economic substance
3.    Basic internal restructuring transactions
4.    Use of SMLLC Conversions
5.    Select internal separation strategies
6.    Common issues in implementing supply chain management and other structures
7.     “Check the box” effective date issues
8.    Modest periods of retroactivity.
9.    The test for “legitimate state interest” means anything that will support the states’ supply of money will provide basis for their findings. 

As the Ernst & Young presenters are working directly with corporations on constant analysis and restructuring projects, they were able to lend a bit of practical experience and findings to the deeper content discussed.  Some of the key areas they see as overall rationale for undertaking these projects (as they can be cumbersome), are:
•    Simplification of organizational structure
•    Realignment of legal structure to be consistent with operational structure
o    Pre-disposition planning
o    Post-acquisition planning
•    Implementation of supply chain management structures either domestically or globally
•    Foreign legal or tax reasons
•    State and local tax reasons (mixing income and loss in state separate return jurisdictions)
•    Reduction of accounting or tax compliance burdens – which was a very common one and one in which the presenters dealt with quite a bit where they saw taking away one box on the org chart saving over $40K per year in just simple burdens alone

My learned colleagues did an excellent job of outlining the various basic internal structural transactions and outlining the issues/considerations.  I have worked with clients in the past to provide data to support the analysis that goes into these types of structural planning opportunities, and am constantly amazed at all the elements that are factored into the analysis.  Just one word to the wise, make sure that a multi-faceted team (including all tax types) are represented early on in the analysis, in order to provide the most value to this analysis and make sure that your “simplified” structure does in fact provide the realized benefits originally intended.

Stay tuned for the second part of the series, which will be posted next week.

 

Fixed Assets ManagerDealing with an audit? Start managing audit communication, record management, collaboration and security with eTaxAuditRoom.

Learn why eTaxAuditRoom will accelerate your tax processes today! Sign up to take a short tour of eTaxAuditRoom today!

Request a Personel Tour Now!

Last modified on Thursday, 22 July 2010 10:34
Kelley Lear

Kelley Lear

E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Add comment


Meet The Authors

Jim is the CEO of Red Moon Solutions, Traci and Kelley are Red Moon's Managing Directors, Stacy serves as Project Manager and Susan is the Manager of Client Services. While each author has a specific role within the Red Moon Solutions team, their overall goal is simple: giving you the information you want. To learn more about an individual author, visit the About the Authors page.

Never Miss A Post!

Never want to miss a post?
Subscribe to the RSS feed here.

Not sure what RSS means?
Click here to learn more.

Search This Blog